 |
|
The
future Gansevoort South Beach and Residences. |
A sign that Miami Beach is still
the place to be: The super-trendy Gansevoort Hotel in
Manhattan’s über-hip Meatpacking District is opening a
southern outpost, Gansevoort South Hotel and Residences,
on Collins Avenue between 23rd and 24th Streets.
Michael Achenbaum, head of the Gansevoort Hotel Group in
New York, hopes to draw to his South Beach venture
throngs of high-class visitors from around the world
willing to drop big bucks for a top-dollar experience.
During the summer off-season, the smallest of the 334
hotel rooms will start at $425 a night. The price will
increase to $625 per night in the busier winter months.
The development will include 259 condominiums; a rooftop
deck with a 110-foot swimming pool; two restaurants, one
by New York Chef Philippe Chow; a ground-level VIP
lounge and more.
But with a successful operation of this magnitude comes
the challenge of being a good neighbor. Creating a
dialogue of understanding between the management of the
Gansevoort and nearby neighbors has been a focus of the
city of Miami Beach Planning Board in recent meetings.
The Gansevoort South is not a new construction project;
rather, it’s a major renovation of the Roney Hotel that
was built in 1968 and closed its doors in August 2004.
The first eight floors of the north tower will be hotel
rooms, and floors nine through 17 will be condominiums.
The 569-unit Roney Palace Condominium, in the south
tower of the complex, was given a facelift by the
Gansevoort developers to make it look fresh and new like
the north tower, but will not change its name.
The Gansevoort South is one more in a series of luxury
condo hotels that are transforming the upper-teens and
low-twenties blocks of Collins Avenue into South Beach’s
next hot neighborhood. Others are the 40-story Setai
that opened a couple of years ago at 20th Street and the
20-story W South Beach Hotel and Residences, which is
scheduled to open in 2009 on the site of the former
Holiday Inn one block north.
No one attending last week’s Miami Beach Planning Board
meeting doubted that the Gansevoort South will be first
class, but they did question the extent to which an
operation of its size will affect the neighbors’ quality
of life. It is one more example of the complex balancing
act between Beach businesses’ rights to prosper and
residents’ rights to live in peace.
The planning board approved the Gansevoort South’s two
restaurants, ballroom, VIP lounge, gym and spa on Aug.
28. But to alleviate neighbors’ concerns that noise and
traffic from the property’s rooftop pool and valet
stands would make their lives miserable, the board
directed the developer to meet with residents of the
Riviera condominium across 24th Street, create a line of
communication and solve foreseeable problems. The
results of their talks were aired at the Sept. 25
planning board meeting.
“We have agreed that the senior hotel manager will meet
with the board of the neighbors to the north on a
monthly basis to ensure dialogue so that we can
proactively address any concerns that arise,” said
Carter McDowell, an attorney representing the project.
He said the developer conducted a test to measure how
sound travels from the Gansevoort South’s rooftop pool
deck to the Riviera condominium.
“Standing outside of the building on the balcony on the
18th floor, they were unable to hear music played on our
rooftop at a level of 82 decibels, not the 75 decibels
that we have limited ourselves to,” McDowell said.
The sound test was taken from the balcony of Moises
Order’s residence at the Riviera. Order is the board
president of the Riviera Condominium Association.
“At 75 [decibels] I did hear the music; it wasn’t too
loud, but I did hear the music,” Order said. He added
that the test was taken with heavy traffic on Collins
Avenue and a noisy construction elevator operating. The
test was conducted without the sound-buffering wall that
the developer plans to build.
The board also discussed plans to minimize traffic and
noise from three valet parking stands and a loading
dock, and address sanitation issues that include garbage
pickup and keeping the streets and gutters clean around
the complex.
Gerald K. Schwartz, an attorney representing the
Riviera, said his clients were satisfied that the
developer was doing what it could to mitigate the impact
on the neighbors, but they were still concerned.
“We would like the right to come back before this board
and express our concerns and let this board hear the
problems and make some decisions,” Schwartz said.
If the developer doesn’t live up to the conditions of
approval, it will be dealt with by either code
compliance or a trip back before the board, testified
Jorge Gomez, director of the Miami Beach Planning
Department.
Before the planning board voted unanimously in favor of
the project, board Chairman Marlo Courtney said the
communication between the developer and the residents at
the Riviera “speaks volumes to what this operation is
going to be.”
He pointed to Jeffrey Chodorow — the restaurateur behind
such high-end restaurants as Blue Door, China Grill,
Social Miami and Tuscan Steak, and others around the
world — who was sitting in the audience.
“You have one of the greatest restaurant operators in
the world who is part of this, a great hotelier,”
Courtney said. “I’m recognizing you, Jeffrey.”
The ironic part of Courtney’s statement is that
Chodorow’s role in the project is not yet confirmed.
“He’s still in negotiations for one of the restaurants
at the Gansevoort South,” Terry Zarikian, director of
product development for Chodorow’s China Grill
Management, said in a telephone interview Monday
morning.
Whether or not Chodorow officially comes onboard is just
one of the unknowns. The other is whether the planning
board’s conditions will work, which brings to mind the
broader issue of how much power any city board has to
regulate relations between businesses and residents.
The Zoning Board of Adjustment, for example, could not
help neighbors of the Table 8 restaurant inside the
Vincci South Beach (formerly the Regent South Beach)
hotel at 1458 Ocean Drive. Though Table 8 is of a much
smaller scale than the Gansevoort South, the board of
adjustment has found itself in the middle of a battle
between the management and upset neighbors.
Neighbors to the north continually complain that music
from an outdoor bar at Table 8 disrupts their serenity
and keeps them awake at night. The owner of Table 8
spent tens of thousands of dollars on sound panels and
other remedies that have helped, but not eliminated, the
problem. The board of adjustment ruled Sept. 7 that it
is powerless to do anything more than it already has
unless the restaurant receives a written noise
violation.
The Gansevoort South Hotel and Residences is scheduled
to open in early 2008, but has already been pushed back
more than once.
“We’re walking into unknown territory because this
hotel building hasn’t really operated for several
years,” said Schwartz, Riviera’s attorney. “We’re really
not sure what’s going to be the outcome.”